If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission
They look just like colored pencils, but watercolor pencils are far more versatile. With cores made with a water-soluble binder, these implements can be used dry or with water for a wide range of effects. Artists can dip the tip of a watercolor pencil into water for a velvety, thick line; they can wet their paper and then draw on it; or they can draw dry, opaque lines and then run a wet brush over their marks. Extremely portable, the pencils are a great alternative to pan or tube watercolors, especially if traveling. Artist-grade watercolor pencils are made with high-quality pigments, offer a high level of lightfastness, and are almost always available by the pencil for easy and economical replacement. Try one—or a few—of our picks below to figure out which you like best.
ARTNEWS RECOMMENDSFaber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolor PencilsFeaturing oil-based cores, these water-soluble pencils perform the most like watercolor paint when wet. The pigment-rich leads are easy to control and spread, and they retain their vibrancy even across larger swaths of paper. They also dissolve with little effort and blend cleanly. The 3.8-millimeter cores are firm to resist snapping when applied with pressure, and they are capable of retaining fine tips for sharp lines. This line also offers outstanding lightfastness, and each pencil is labeled with its rating for convenience. Pencils are sold individually or in sets and are available in a comprehensive range of 120 colors.
Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolor Pencils
WE ALSO LIKECaran d’Ache Supracolor Aquarelle Pencils and SetsSlightly softer than the Albrecht Dürers, the Supracolors are a slightly pricier series that we consider an upgrade pick. These pencils, which feature a 3.7-millimeter core, are beloved for their easy blendability, smooth strokes, and lively colors. They lay down almost buttery lines and layer and blend smoothly whether wet or dry, and their pigments can be activated to produce stunning washes. Their priciness—nearly $3 per pencil when purchased individually—drops them to number two on our list, and they also lose some points for lightfastness: Some colors do not have excellent ratings, so be sure to check before you buy.
Caren d’Ache Supracolor Soft Aquarelle Pencils and Sets
STUDENTS’ CHOICEWinsor & Newton Studio Collection Colour Pencils, Set of 48A relative newcomer to the watercolor pencil market, Winsor & Newton’s series is a great choice for artists who want to use professional-grade watercolors without spending too much. These wax-based pencils are similar in softness to the Supracolors (with the same core size) and lay down very vivid, almost luminous colors. Wet or dry, they also blend effortlessly and layer well, with pigments staying bright without muddying. We judge them best for students for two reasons: You can purchase them only in sets of 4 to 48, not by the pencil, and they do not have lightfastness ratings.
Winsor & Newton Studio Collection Color Pencils, Set of 48
ANOTHER OPTIONDerwent Inktense Pencils and SetsIn performance, Derwent’s pencils are similar to watercolor pencils, but they are technically made with water-soluble, highly pigmented ink. The result: extremely intense colors that can be applied wet to produce bold strokes and washes. Once dry, the marks are permanent—so while this is not the most forgiving water-soluble medium, it is excellent to use for layering when you want to leave underlying layers undisturbed. These pencils are compatible with paper as well as fabric and are a great complement to traditional watercolor pencils.
Derwent Inktense Pencils and Sets
ALSO CONSIDERPrismacolor Premier Watercolor Pencils, Set of 36Prismacolor has long maintained a reputation for superior colored pencils, and this set of 36 watercolor pencils are no exception. They are soft and pigment-rich and showcase excellent mixing ability. You can achieve smooth, saturated color on most papers; when hydrated, the colors can produce scintillating, translucent, watery effects. The full spectrum of hues—which includes neutrals, metallics, and several shades of gray, are lightfast.
Prismacolor Premier Watercolor Pencils, Set of 36
Brought to you by the oldest and most widely circulated art magazine in the world, ARTnews Recommends helps you make the choice that suits you best from products in hundreds of art and craft supply categories. Our offerings are based on intensive research, interviews with artists and craftspeople, and the accumulated experience of the site’s editors and writers. We provide trustworthy and helpful advice about materials to artists ranging from beginner to professional.